Current:Home > InvestFederal court rules firearm restrictions on defendants awaiting trial are constitutional-InfoLens
Federal court rules firearm restrictions on defendants awaiting trial are constitutional
View Date:2024-12-23 18:17:01
SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — Court orders that prohibited two criminal defendants from possessing firearms while they awaited trial were constitutional because they were in line with past restrictions on firearms, a federal court ruled Monday.
Judge Gabriel P. Sanchez, writing for a unanimous three-judge panel of the U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals, found that U.S. laws have historically sought to disarm dangerous criminal defendants, the Los Angeles Times reported.
Sanchez said those previous prohibitions justified the restrictions placed on John Thomas Fencl and Jesus Perez-Garcia, defendants in California whose challenges to the law were consolidated in Monday’s order.
“Here, the historical evidence, when considered as a whole, shows a long and broad history of legislatures exercising authority to disarm people whose possession of firearms would pose an unusual danger, beyond the ordinary citizen, to themselves or others,” Sanchez wrote. “The temporary disarmament of Fencl and Perez-Garcia as a means reasonably necessary to protect public safety falls within that historical tradition.”
Katie Hurrelbrink, an attorney for both men, told the Times she intended to “continue litigating this” by asking for a review by a larger, en banc appellate panel and, if necessary, the U.S. Supreme Court.
U.S. Attorney Tara McGrath said in a statement that the ruling “recognized the long history of keeping firearms out of the hands of those who refuse to abide by the law.”
The Times cited court records that show Fencl was arrested and charged with various crimes after law enforcement officials discovered more than 100 guns in his home near San Diego. Perez-Garcia was arrested at the U.S.-Mexico border when a customs inspection of a vehicle in which he was a passenger uncovered about 11 kilograms of methamphetamine and half a kilogram of fentanyl, court records show.
Both Fencl and Perez-Garcia argued that while detained defendants had historically had firearms taken away from them, there was no historical record of detainees who had been released from detention being precluded from possessing firearms.
Sanchez wrote that the decision to take their guns was “consistent with our nation’s long history of temporarily disarming criminal defendants facing serious charges and those deemed dangerous or unwilling to follow the law.”
Both men were released from custody pending trial and subsequently challenged the terms of their release under a “history and tradition” test the U.S. Supreme Court established in 2022 for assessing the constitutionality of gun laws nationwide. In New York State Rifle & Pistol Assn. vs. Bruen, the high court said that gun laws are legitimate only if they are rooted in U.S. history and tradition or are sufficiently analogous to some historic law.
The Bruen decision led to a surge in challenges to gun laws.
veryGood! (68344)
Related
- Alexandra Daddario Shares Candid Photo of Her Postpartum Body 6 Days After Giving Birth
- Super Bowl 58 picks: Will 49ers or Chiefs win out on NFL's grand stage in Las Vegas?
- Who sang the national anthem at the 2024 Super Bowl? All about Reba McEntire
- Andy Reid changes the perception of him, one 'nuggies' ad at a time
- Subway rider who helped restrain man in NYC chokehold death says he wanted ex-Marine to ‘let go’
- Chiefs WR Kadarius Toney inactive for Super Bowl 2024
- Travis Kelce Has Heated Moment with Coach Andy Reid on Field at Super Bowl 2024
- House sets second Mayorkas impeachment vote for Tuesday
- 5-year-old boy who went missing while parent was napping is found dead near Oregon home, officials say
- How a Climate Group That Has Made Chaos Its Brand Got the White House’s Ear
Ranking
- Ford agrees to pay up to $165 million penalty to US government for moving too slowly on recalls
- Valerie Bertinelli ditched the scale after being 'considered overweight' at 150 pounds
- ‘Lisa Frankenstein’ fails to revive North American box office on a very slow Super Bowl weekend
- Nebraska upsets No. 2 Iowa: Caitlin Clark 8 points from scoring record
- Police identify 7-year-old child killed in North Carolina weekend shooting
- Fans turned away, alcohol sales halted at Phoenix Open as TPC Scottsdale reaches capacity
- Super Bowl 58 bold predictions: Six strong claims for Chiefs vs. 49ers
- Kanye West criticized by Ozzy Osbourne, Donna Summer's estate for allegedly using uncleared samples for new album
Recommendation
-
Secret Service Agent Allegedly Took Ex to Barack Obama’s Beach House
-
Maryland man becomes second winner of $5 million from 50 Years scratch-off game
-
Weird & Clever Products on Amazon That Will Make Your Home so Much Cooler
-
Ozzy Osbourne threatens legal action after Ye reportedly sampled Black Sabbath in new song
-
Joey Graziadei Details Why Kelsey Anderson Took a Break From Social Media
-
Chiefs WR Kadarius Toney inactive for Super Bowl 2024
-
The Wicked Behind-the-Scenes Drama of the Original Charmed: Feuds, Firings and Feminist Fury
-
Super Bowl winners throughout history: Full list from 2023 all the way back to the first in 1967